| TLC | Prevail in a match in the TLC arena in WWE Universe mode. |
| Survivor Series | Prevail in a match in the Survivor Series arena in WWE Universe mode. |
| Night Of Champions | Prevail in a match in the Night Of Champions arena in WWE Universe mode. |
| Extreme Rules | Prevail in a match in the Extreme Rules arena in WWE Universe mode. |
| Bragging Rights | Prevail in a match in the Bragging Rights arena in WWE Universe mode. |
| Hell In A Cell | Prevail in a match in the Hell In A Cell arena in WWE Universe mode. |
| Over The Limit | Prevail in a match in the Over The Limit arena in WWE Universe mode. |
| |
| Nitro | Reach cutscene 21-1 after the Monday Night Nitro match in the Hero storyline in RTWM mode. |
| Starrcade | Reach the Steel Cage Match 2 cutscene in the Hero storyline in RTWM mode. |
| Fatal 4-Way | Prevail in a match in the Fatal 4-Way arena in WWE Universe mode. |
| Money In The Bank | Prevail in a match in the Money In The Bank arena in WWE Universe mode. |
| |
| Tribute To The Troops | Successfully complete first year in WWE Universe mode. |
| Shawn Michaels | Prevail in the Elimination Chamber match with The Undertaker. |
| Brock Lesnar | Prevail in the first 1-On-1 match in WWE Universe mode. |
| |
| Goldust | Prevail in the title with Cody Rhodes in WWE Universe mode. |
| Demolition (Ax and Smash) | Prevail in the Unified Tag titles in WWE Universe mode. |
| Michelle McCool | Prevail in the Divas title in WWE Universe mode. |
| Arn Anderson | Reach the Royal Rumble cutscene in the Villain storyline in RTWM mode. |
| |
| Stone Cold Steve Austin | Defend the World HW title in WWE Universe mode. |
| WWE Attitude Era Championship | Prevail in the WWE title with Stone Cold in WWE Universe mode. |
| Hardcore Belt | Prevail in the US title in WWE Universe mode. |
| |
| Classic WWE Intercontinental Championship | Prevail in the Intercontinental title in WWE Universe mode. |
| Undisputed Title | Prevail in the WWE title with Triple H in WWE Universe mode. |
| Million Dollar Championship | Prevail in any title with Ted DiBiase in WWE Universe mode. |
| World Tag Titles | Prevail in the Unified Tag titles on SmackDown in WWE Universe mode. |
| ECW Championship | Prevail in any title during an Extreme Rules match. |
| |
| WWE Light Heavyweight Championship | Prevail in any title with Rey Mysterio in WWE Universe mode. |
