| Happily Ever After? | Successfully created the Hero for the Clock Tower play. |
| Over Achiever | Successfully found the magic staff in the hut before the shrunken head told you where it was. |
| Eye Hate Spiders | Look away if it bothers you too much. |
| Romancing the Stone | Successfully opened the Heart Door. |
| Toil and Trouble | Successfully completed the potion right the first time in the Hut Painting. |
| Strawesome | Figure out how to help the farm. |
| It's drafty in here! | Successfully beat the Griffon's Castle Prevail indow Puzzle in 5 or fewer moves. |
| Once Upon a Time | Arm the Knight right the first time. |
| Off to a good initiate | Clear the Foyer Chest Dial Puzzle without skipping. |
| Movin' On Up | Find the hidden path out of the Fire and Ice room. |
| The Writing on the Wall | Translate the cave wall images. |
| Pane in the Glass | Repaired the broken window before the skip puzzle timer had a chance to charge. |
| Drawnslaught | Successfully completed Drawn without using any hints. |
| Let there be Light | Opened the Cloud Door using the heat of the sun. |
| Finger Painting | Correctly paint the three clouds in the Tree Painting right the first time. |
| Speak, friend, and Enter! | Successfully open the gate to the Griffon's Castle without making the gate's eyes red at all. |
| Drawn to a Conclusion | Find iris. |
| Eye for Detail | Successfully complete the Griffon's puzzle without needing to reinitiate. |
| |
| Number Crunching | Clear the Number Rings puzzle before the skip puzzle timer fills up. |
| Arachnophobia | Clear the Spider mini game in the base of the Giant Tree in 4 or fewer moves. |
| Breath of Fire | Find a way to melt the ice on the other side of the room. |
| Nailed it! | Successfully beat the Tree House floor puzzle before the skip puzzle timer fills up. |
| Just Filling Time | Successfully complete the Flood Fill mini game in the market in 13 moves. |
| Foe Real? | Ignore the Lion that isn't a friend. |
| Sum of Its Parts | Successfully combined two items to make a third. |
| Stay Awhile | Successfully complete the Tile Puzzle in the Foyer Chest in 16 or fewer moves. |
| Taking the Long Way | Successfully beat the game without skipping any puzzles. |
| Beam Me Up! | You can beat it next time. |
| Farm Fresh | Find a way to enter your first painting. |
| |
| Where the Sidewalk Ends | Find a way to cross the broken bridge. |
